Formats

Pauper vs Commander: differences and which to choose to start playing Magic

Pauper vs Commander: differences and which to choose to start playing Magic
The short answer: choose Commander if you want relaxed multiplayer games with friends, and Pauper if you prefer one-on-one games, leagues and an affordable competitive format. Both can be started on a small budget.

Would you rather receive your Pauper deck assembled?Build your Pauper deck from €32

Differences between Pauper and Commander

AspectPauperCommander
PlayersOne-on-oneUsually four
Deck sizeAt least 60 cards and up to 15 in the sideboardExactly 100 cards including the commander
Copies of each cardUp to fourOne, except basic lands
Allowed cardsCommons onlyAlmost every card
Starting life2040
Typical length15 to 25 minutes per gameOne to two hours
AtmosphereLeagues and tournamentsSocial games with friends

To learn each format in depth, read what Pauper is and what Commander is.

Choose Pauper if…

  • You like one-on-one games and testing yourself against other players.
  • You want to play leagues or tournaments without spending much money.
  • You prefer short games where every decision counts.
  • You enjoy following the metagame and tuning your sideboard.

Choose Commander if…

  • You mostly play with friends and enjoy four-player games.
  • You want to build around a favourite card.
  • You like spectacular plays and longer games.
  • You prefer a social atmosphere over a competitive one.

Budget: how much it costs to start

In Pauper every card is a common, so a competitive deck costs far less than in other constructed formats. In Commander the price depends on the power level you want: a casual list can be very affordable and a highly optimised one quite expensive.

At Deck Lab both services start at €32: you can create your custom Commander deck or order a custom Pauper deck, and in both cases you review the list and budget before assembly.

What if I want to try both?

That is very common. Many players have a Commander deck for evenings with friends and a Pauper deck for their store league. If you are starting from scratch, we recommend this order:

  1. Learn the basic rules with a one-on-one game.
  2. Pick the format your group or store plays most.
  3. Get a complete, legal list before modifying it.
To choose a specific deck, compare the best Pauper decks of 2026 with our budget Commander decks.

Content reviewed: 27 September 2026.

Custom Pauper deckWould you rather receive your Pauper deck assembled?

You choose the goal, archetype and budget; we prepare the 60 common cards and the 15-card sideboard and show you the list before assembly.

Build your Pauper deck from €32

Frequently asked questions

Which is cheaper, Pauper or Commander?

It depends on the list, but Pauper is usually cheaper to play competitively because it only uses commons. Casual Commander also has affordable decks, and at Deck Lab both custom deck services start at €32.

Which format is better for playing with friends?

Commander is designed for relaxed multiplayer games, usually with four people. Pauper is one-on-one and is a better fit if you are looking for leagues or tournaments.

Can I use the same cards in both formats?

Many commons are legal in both, but deckbuilding is different: Commander uses a single copy of each card across exactly 100 cards, while Pauper allows up to four copies in a 60-card deck.

Is there a Pauper Commander format?

Yes, there is a variant called Pauper Commander or PDH, with 100 common cards and an uncommon commander. It is a different format from the classic 60-card Pauper covered in this guide.